The complete guide
🏆Baby shower game prizes
Need prizes for your game winners? You don't need many, and you don't need to overthink it. Here's how many to get, what people actually love winning, and a top-rated pick for every budget.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices are approximate — check Amazon. Ratings reflect Amazon reviews at last update.
How prizes work — in 60 seconds
How many?
Plan 1–2 prizes per game. 3–5 games = keep 4–8 small prizes on hand. Wrap them so they look special.
Who's winning?
Most guests are women, so spa, cozy and sweet picks are safe. Co-ed shower? Add a couple of universal items.
How much?
$10–$20 each is the sweet spot. Splurge a little on one 'grand prize' and keep the rest smaller.
Tip: Don't gift-card it. A small, wrapped, useful item feels more thoughtful than a $5 gift card — and costs about the same.
Which prizes for which crowd
Pick the lane that matches your shower.
🥇The grand prize
One bigger win
- ✓A nicer spa box or a Stanley tumbler for the top scorer
- ✓Makes the games feel worth playing
- ✓Spend ~$25–30 here, less on the rest
Buy: A spa gift set or the Stanley tumbler
🎁A handful of small prizes
Several winners
- ✓Keep 4–8 small, wrapped prizes ready
- ✓Candles, socks, lip balm, chocolate, a succulent
- ✓$8–15 each so it adds up gently
Buy: Cozy socks, lip balm, a candle, chocolate
👫Co-ed shower
Works for everyone
- ✓Add universal picks anyone's happy to win
- ✓A good tumbler, gourmet chocolate
- ✓Skip spa-only items as the main prize
Buy: A Stanley tumbler + a chocolate box
🏢Office / work shower
Tasteful & neutral
- ✓Desk-friendly, no strong scents at work
- ✓A nice tumbler, chocolate, a small plant
- ✓Keep it modest — $10–15
Buy: A tumbler, chocolate, or a succulent
What to actually buy
If you grab nothing else, get one grand prize and a few small ones. Everything else is a nice-to-have.
🥇The grand prize
Start hereOne nicer prize for your top scorer makes the games feel worth playing. Spend a little more here than on the rest.
What to look for: Something that feels like a treat: a multi-piece spa set, or a viral-favourite like a Stanley tumbler. Gender-neutral so anyone's happy to win it.
13-Piece Relaxing Spa Gift Set
A relaxing grand-prize box
Nurture by Nature Spa Gift Basket
A relaxing grand-prize box — 4.7★
Stanley IceFlow Tumbler (20 oz)
The viral-favourite grand prize
🎁A handful of small prizes
Start hereMost of your prizes are these — small, wrapped, universally-liked items. Keep 4–8 on hand.
What to look for: Cozy, sweet or self-care items in the $8–18 range. A mix is best so winners can pick.
Unboxme Ultra-Soft Cozy Cloud Socks
Crowd-pleaser, beautifully boxed
Burt's Bees Lip Balm (4-pack)
A small, everyone-likes-it prize
Burt's Bees Hand Repair Gift Set
Always useful, feels premium
Aromatherapy Shower Steamers (18 pk)
Spa-at-home, gender-neutral
Live Succulents (6-pack)
A charming little living prize
🍫Sweet treats
Chocolate and cookies are the easiest crowd-pleaser — no one's disappointed to win candy.
What to look for: A boxed, giftable presentation beats a loose bag. Recognisable brands feel more premium.
Godiva Signature Truffle Gift Box (15 pc)
Premium pick — instantly recognised
Barnetts Gourmet Chocolate Cookies Box
Sweet, giftable, ready to gift
🕯️Cozy & home
A candle or a soft blanket feels like a treat and photographs well on the prize table.
What to look for: A single nice candle reads more giftable than a bulk pack. A best-selling soft blanket makes a memorable top prize.
Bath & Body Works 3-Wick Candle
A candle everyone recognises and loves
Bedsure Soft Fleece Blanket
Cozy, best-selling — a great top prize
Now the fun part
Don't forget the games
20 interactive baby shower games that play on any screen — no printing, no prep. Start the emoji game free.